Paid a Contractor by Credit Card or PayPal: Do I Still Send a 1099?
You paid your video editor through your business credit card, your marketer through PayPal, and your handyman by check. Now it is year end and you are wondering whether all three get a 1099.
In general they do not, and this is the single most common mistake on these forms. Payments made by credit card, debit card or a third-party payment network are typically reported by the payment processor, not by you. Report them again and the same money is counted twice. Here is how to handle it, with a worked example and the formula.
Record-keeping guidance only, not tax advice. Confirm how the rules apply to you with the IRS or your accountant.
The logic in plain English
When you pay by card or through a payment network, a third party sees the transaction and reports it to the IRS on its own form. The contractor receives that form. If you also put the amount on your 1099-NEC, the IRS sees it twice.
That means the method of payment matters as much as the amount. Your tracker needs a payment-method column on every row.
Worked example: same contractor, two payment methods
Fictional numbers, assumed $2,000 threshold:
| Contractor | ACH / check | Card / app | Total paid | Reportable by you | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jordan Lee | $1,400 | $900 | $2,300 | $1,400 | Below threshold |
| Lakeside Media | $0 | $4,500 (PayPal G&S) | $4,500 | $0 | No form from you |
| Tom Reyes | $2,100 | $0 | $2,100 | $2,100 | Form required |
If you simply added everything, you would conclude that all three need forms, and you would be wrong about two of them. Across these three contractors you paid $8,900 in total, but only $3,500 is yours to report.
The formula
Put the payment method in column D (use a drop-down: ACH, Check, Cash, Credit card, PayPal G&S, Venmo business, Stripe) and the amount in column C. In column F, calculate the reportable amount:
=IF(OR(D2="Credit card",D2="PayPal G&S",D2="Venmo business",D2="Stripe"),0,C2)
Then total per contractor from column F, not column C:
=SUMIFS(Ledger!F:F,Ledger!B:B,A2)
Add a second total from column C if you want to see how much you paid overall, and a third showing the difference, which is the amount someone else is reporting. In the example above that difference is $5,400.
Mistakes to avoid
- Adding everything in one column. Without a method column you cannot separate the amounts later.
- Typing the method as free text. “paypal”, “PayPal” and “PP” will not match your formula. Use a drop-down.
- Paying by personal-transfer options. Friends-and-family style transfers are not meant for business payments and can create their own problems.
- Assuming no form means no records. Keep the payment record and the W-9 regardless. You still deduct the expense.
- Skipping the W-9 because the payment was by card. You may still need the contractor’s details for other reporting, so collect it anyway.
Copy-ready check
- Add a “Payment method” drop-down to every ledger row.
- Back-fill the method for this year from your statements.
- Add the reportable-amount column.
- Compare total paid with reportable total for each contractor.
- Run the threshold test on the reportable total only.
For the full process around this step, including the threshold test, roster and filing checklist, see the main guide: 1099 contractor payment tracker spreadsheet for Excel and Google Sheets. And if you are still working out who counts as a contractor in the first place, read contractor or employee: a checklist for small business owners.
The 1099 Contractor Payment Tracker handles this automatically. Set the payment method on each row and the file removes card and payment-network payments from your reportable totals on its own, with a complete fictional sample year loaded so you can watch it work. It works in Excel and Google Sheets.
Featured on ReadySheetGo
1099 Contractor Payment Tracker — $16.99
Automatic exclusion of card and third-party-network payments from your reportable totals. Works in Excel and Google Sheets.
General information only, not tax, legal or accounting advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I send a 1099-NEC for payments made by credit card?
Generally no. Payments made by credit card, debit card or through a third-party payment network are reported by the payment processor on Form 1099-K, so you leave them off your own 1099-NEC. Confirm how this applies to your situation with the IRS or your accountant.
What about PayPal, Venmo and Stripe?
Payments made through a third-party payment network, for example PayPal goods and services, Venmo business or Stripe, are generally reported by that network. Payments sent as personal or friends-and-family transfers are a different matter, and you should not use those to pay for business services.
What if I paid one contractor partly by ACH and partly by card?
Only the ACH, check or cash portion counts toward your own reporting. If that portion is below the threshold, no form is needed from you even though the contractor's total receipts were higher.
Why does this matter for my spreadsheet?
If your tracker adds every payment, you will overstate who needs a form and report the same money twice. A payment-method column with a formula that zeroes out card and payment-app payments keeps the totals honest.