Contractor or Employee Checklist for Small Business Owners

You hired a part-time designer six months ago. She works set hours, uses your laptop, takes direction from you every day, and you pay her a flat amount every two weeks. You have been treating her as a contractor because that is how it started. Is that right?

A contractor or employee checklist will not give you a legal answer, but it shows how the relationship looks when you line it up with the factors regulators and courts commonly weigh. This one has 15 questions in three groups, with a scoring method you can build in a spreadsheet in ten minutes.

This checklist is a prompt for a conversation with your accountant or an attorney, not a determination. Rules vary by agency and by state.

The three groups

Classification is usually considered across three areas.

Behavioral control covers whether you direct how the work is done: instructions, training, set hours, required methods.

Financial control covers the business side of the relationship: who supplies tools, who bears expenses, whether the worker can make a profit or loss, and whether they serve other clients.

Nature of the relationship covers the paperwork and permanence: written contracts, benefits, whether the work is a core part of your business, and whether the arrangement is open-ended.

The 15-question checklist

Score each answer: 0 means it looks like a contractor, 1 means it is mixed, 2 means it looks like an employee.

Behavioral control

  1. Do you set the worker’s hours or require specific shifts?
  2. Do you tell them how to do the work, not just what result you want?
  3. Do you train them in your methods?
  4. Must they work at your location or follow your internal processes?
  5. Do you supervise or review their work as it happens?

Financial control

  1. Do you supply the tools, equipment or software?
  2. Do you reimburse their business expenses?
  3. Is payment by the hour or week rather than by project?
  4. Are they prevented from, or discouraged from, working for others?
  5. Can they not realistically make a profit or loss on the job?

Nature of the relationship

  1. Is the arrangement open-ended rather than for a defined project?
  2. Is the work a core part of what your business does every day?
  3. Do you offer anything resembling benefits, paid time off or bonuses?
  4. Do they present themselves to your clients as part of your team?
  5. Is it unclear whether there is a written agreement, or does the agreement say one thing while practice says another?

Worked example: scoring the designer

Fictional answers for the part-time designer above:

Group Questions Score Max
Behavioral control Set hours (2), direction (2), training (1), your location (1), supervision (2) 8 10
Financial control Your laptop (2), no reimbursement (0), paid biweekly (2), other clients allowed (0), no profit/loss (2) 6 10
Relationship Open-ended (2), core work (1), no benefits (0), on team page (2), contract unclear (1) 6 10
Total 20 30

20 out of 30 is a high score. A common way to read it: 0 to 10 looks like a contractor, 11 to 18 is mixed, and 19 to 30 looks like an employee. The thresholds are your own arbitrary cut-offs, which is why the output is a flag to discuss, not a verdict.

Building the scoring in a spreadsheet

Put the questions in column A and a drop-down in column B with values 0, 1 and 2. Group subtotals:

=SUM(B2:B6)

=SUM(B7:B11)

=SUM(B12:B16)

Total and reading:

=SUM(C2:C4)

=IF(D2<=10,"Looks like a contractor",IF(D2<=18,"Mixed - review","Looks like an employee - talk to your accountant"))

If you want weights, for example counting hours and supervision more heavily, add a weight column and use =SUMPRODUCT(B2:B16,C2:C16).

What to do with a high score

  1. Do not panic and do not ignore it.
  2. Write down what the real working arrangement is today.
  3. Bring the sheet to your accountant or an employment attorney.
  4. Consider changing the arrangement, such as moving to project-based pricing, or reclassifying the worker.
  5. Keep the checklist with your records for the year.

For how this fits with tracking payments, W-9s and year-end forms, read the main guide: 1099 contractor payment tracker spreadsheet for Excel and Google Sheets. If you also need to settle who counts as reportable, see which contractors need a 1099-NEC.

The 1099 Contractor Payment Tracker includes a Worker Classification tab: a 15-question weighted self-check across behavioral control, financial control and the nature of the relationship, producing a risk score and a reading. It sits beside the roster, payment ledger and W-9 chase list in one file that works in Excel and Google Sheets.

General information only, not tax, legal or accounting advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if someone is a contractor or an employee?

Agencies and courts generally look at the whole relationship, commonly grouped into behavioral control (who directs how the work is done), financial control (who controls the business side, such as tools, expenses and profit or loss), and the nature of the relationship (contracts, benefits, permanence). No single factor decides it. A scored checklist is a prompt for a conversation with your accountant, not a determination.

Does a signed contractor agreement settle it?

No. A contract is one piece of evidence, but how the work is actually done matters more than what the paperwork says.

What is the risk of misclassifying a worker?

Potential back taxes, penalties and interest, plus possible state-level consequences. The exact exposure depends on your state and situation, so ask a qualified professional before relying on a classification.

Can a tracker decide classification for me?

No. It can organise your answers and show where a worker looks like an employee, so you can raise it with an accountant or attorney before it becomes an issue.

Know Who You Owe a 1099 To, and Whose W-9 Is Still Missing

The 1099 Contractor Payment Tracker — 12 linked tabs and 2,785 working formulas for the money you pay out to contractors: a Dashboard showing forms required, reportable spend, W-9s outstanding and withholding at risk; a 50-contractor Roster; a 250-row Payment Ledger that categorises itself and automatically excludes card and third-party-network payments; a 1099 Determination tab that gives every contractor a plain-English verdict; a W-9 Chase List with follow-up dates and priced backup-withholding exposure; Box Mapping and per-box totals; a Filing Checklist with live deadline countdowns; ten automatic Year-End Close-Out checks; a 15-question Worker Classification self-check; and a Multi-Year Archive. Works in Excel and Google Sheets, no macros and no add-ons. Organises your records; not tax or legal advice.

View on Etsy — $16.99